Back to Industry Insights

FP Meetup / Showcase Reflections with Ali Coffey

In this practical session, Fishpond’s Sean speaks with Ali Coffey, casting director and founder of Fishpond, about how casters actually use the platform and what makes a profile stand out. Ali explains why many roles never appear on the projects board, how she filters searches, and what makes her stop on a profile: the face first, then the footage. She also answers questions from members on children’s profiles, showreel formats, working without Irish representation and choosing a base location.

Her message is clear and encouraging. Casters search by who fits the role, not by who has an agent or the longest list of credits. Roughly half the actors on Fishpond are represented and half aren’t, and Ali casts both all the time. What helps most is a profile that’s honest, current and complete. That means photos that look like you today, an honest playing age and skills list, a tagline with some context, and good footage. Even self-shot footage counts, because it lets a caster see what you can do.

Original Date 6th October 2026
FP Host Sean
Guest Ali Coffey, Casting Director and Founder of Fishpond

KEY TAKEAWAYS

1 Not Every Role Is Posted
Around half of briefs go on the projects board. Roles that are very niche or confidential, or that need options in a hurry, are cast by searching the database directly, so your profile has to do the work for you.

2 Keep Your Playing Age Honest
Keep your playing age within about five years of your real age, and never use a range wider than ten years. A narrow, accurate range means you come up in the searches that are actually relevant to you.

3 Your Photo Should Look Like You Today
You don’t need the most expensive photographer in town. A clean, current shot against a plain background, even one taken on a phone, beats a polished headshot that no longer looks like you. Add a few photos showing different sides of you.

4 Footage Is Your Calling Card
If Ali doesn’t know you, her first question is whether you can act. Upload a minute or two each of a couple of contrasting scenes, such as comedy and drama, and label everything so casters know what they’re clicking into.

5 Take Your Time Over Self-Made Scenes
Work with an actor friend as your reader if you can, and make sure they don’t drown you out. Choose material you love and can play truthfully, and feel free to adapt it by changing the gender or age. Do several takes and get honest feedback before you upload.

6 Tell the Truth About Your Skills
Only list skills, horse riding included, that you can genuinely deliver. Put your native accent first, and only add other accents you could do flawlessly on the spot. Add Irish or any other languages you speak. A driving licence is the skill casters search for most.

7 Use Your Tagline
Ali reads the tagline on every profile. Use it to give context a tick-box can’t, such as awards, a previous career or time spent living abroad.

8 Curate Your Credits
Put your most recent work first, drop credits you’ve outgrown and keep any older one that marked a turning point. Casters want to see quickly where you are in your career now. Skip the montage or music at the start of a showreel and go straight into the action.

9 Shoot a Reusable Ident
Record one good ident: face to full length, name, height, agent or independent status, and optionally your profiles and hands. Attach it to every self-tape so each audition you can focus on the scene itself.

10 Stay Reachable and Connected
Casting moves fast, so make sure you can be contacted the same day and that your Fishpond notifications are switched on. Link to friends and family on the new platform so casters can find you when they need people with real-life chemistry. Set a recurring three-month reminder to review your whole profile.

MEMORABLE QUOTES

“I’m searching by who fits the criteria for this individual role.”
Ali explained that she isn’t searching by who has an agent or by the things actors might assume. Each search starts from the specific needs of the role, which is why a complete, accurate profile matters so much.

“The camera doesn’t lie, sadly.”
She was talking about why playing ages should stay close to your real age. The closer the camera gets, the more your eyes and life experience show, and no one can convincingly play both 18 and 45 on screen.

“Does this look like me today?”
This is the question she wants every actor to ask about their main headshot. If the answer is no, you know what your next job is.

“Can they act? That’s our first question.”
When a caster comes across someone they don’t know, looking the part is only the start. Footage, even self-shot scenes, answers the question that matters most.

“Don’t rush it, that is a job to take your time over.”
Ali’s advice on adding scenes to your profile was to do multiple takes, ask trusted friends in the business for honest feedback, and only upload once you’re truly happy with the result.

“Be honest about your skills.”
Horse riding is the skill actors most often exaggerate, and it gets found out, sometimes on horseback at a screen test, which isn’t safe. The same goes for accents: only list the ones you could do cold.

“Sometimes a fresh face is exactly what we’re looking for.”
Being newer to the profession isn’t a mark against you. Ali encouraged actors to be honest about their experience level, whatever stage they’re at.

“That’s your space, and use it.”
On the tagline: whether it’s an award, a previous career as a nurse or fluency in another language, a little context brings a profile to life far more than a ticked box.

“It’s not a glamorous skill, but it’s the one we search the most.”
On driving licences: if you don’t have one, Ali suggests making it a goal for the next year or two, because it’s one of the most useful things an actor can have.

“Our job is to find the right person for the role wherever they may come from.”
Asked whether having Irish representation matters, Ali said no. Fishpond is roughly half represented and half unrepresented, and the only requirement is a permit to work in the country.

“It levels the playing field a bit, which I’m a fan of.”
On remote first-round auditions, Ali said they save actors money, let casters see far more people, and suit actors who are fitting self-tapes around other work.

Submit Feedback